Montévane

Jewelry Guides

Engagement Ring Buying Guide: Shape, Setting and Stone

· 3 min read

Radiant & Pear-Shaped Diamond Toi et Moi Engagement Ring, 18K White Gold

December is the most popular month of the year to propose, and most people buy the ring in the weeks before. If that's you, this guide is the short version of everything a jeweller would tell you.

Start with what she'll notice – the shape and the setting – then decide where to spend on the stone. For the grading details, see our diamond buying guide.

1. Choose the shape

Shape is the first thing anyone sees and the most personal choice. Round brilliants sparkle most; elongated shapes (oval, pear, emerald) look larger for their weight and flatter the finger.

ShapeLookGood to know
RoundClassic, maximum sparkleThe most expensive per carat
OvalElegant, elongates the fingerCheck for a "bow-tie" shadow across the centre
EmeraldArchitectural, Art DecoShows inclusions – choose higher clarity
PearRomantic, distinctiveProtect the point with a V-prong
CushionSoft, vintageWide variation in cutting styles
RadiantBrilliant sparkle, rectangular outlineHides inclusions well

See every shape compared in our diamond shapes guide.

2. Choose the setting

  • Solitaire – one stone, timeless, lets the diamond speak.
  • Halo – a circle of small diamonds that makes the centre look larger.
  • Three-stone – past, present and future; wonderful with a fancy colour centre.
  • Toi et Moi – two stones side by side, "you and me". The most requested style of the moment. Read Toi et Moi rings explained.
  • Eternity band – diamonds all the way round; increasingly chosen as the engagement ring itself.

3. Choose the metal

Platinum is dense, naturally white and very durable – the choice for most fine engagement rings. 18k white gold looks similar, is lighter and slightly more affordable, and is rhodium-plated for its bright white finish (the plating is renewed every few years). Yellow and rose gold suit warmer skin tones and vintage styles, and make fancy yellow diamonds glow.

4. Where to spend on the stone

  • Cut first. A well-cut diamond looks bigger and brighter than a poorly cut one of the same weight.
  • Colour: G–H looks white in a platinum setting; in yellow gold you can go lower.
  • Clarity: VS2–SI1 is usually "eye-clean" in round and oval stones; choose higher for emerald cuts.
  • Carat: buy just below the round numbers – a 0.95 ct looks the same as a 1.00 ct and costs noticeably less.

Always ask for the grading report and learn how to read a GIA report.

5. Find her size without asking

Borrow a ring she wears on her ring finger (the right hand works if needed – sizes are often similar) and have a jeweller measure it, or press it into soap to keep its outline. If in doubt, go slightly larger: making a ring smaller is easier than making it bigger, and eternity bands can't be resized at all.

Shop this guide

Available now at Montévane

Shop the guide

Frequently asked questions

How much should I spend on an engagement ring?

There is no rule. Decide your budget first, then choose shape and setting, and spend what's left on cut quality before carat weight.

Is platinum better than white gold for an engagement ring?

Platinum is more durable and stays white without plating; white gold is lighter and slightly more affordable. Both are excellent choices.

Can an engagement ring be resized?

Most solitaire, halo and three-stone rings can be resized by one or two sizes. Full eternity bands generally cannot, so measure carefully.

Sources

Back to Journal

More Stories